We have applied for appeal
Our legal team have applied to the judge for permission to appeal against the decision she made in our judicial review of the GMC over their failure to define a scope of practice for Physician … Read more
Case dismissed
We are hugely disappointed that Mrs Justice Lambert has dismissed our judicial review on all grounds. She has accepted everything that Professor Melville and the GMC have said, despite the flaws in their argument. Her … Read more
GMC makes submission to court over Leng
Following the publication of the Leng review, there may be further delays in getting our verdict as the GMC has asked the court to look at how this review affects our claim. The GMC, BMA … Read more
Leng – a bold move in the right direction
In her long-awaited report on Associates, Professor Leng has set out 18 recommendations. The most significant of these is that the title of “physician associate” and “anaesthesia associate” should now be downgraded to physician assistant … Read more
We fought for safety
Our judicial review of the GMC has finished and we are anxiously waiting for Mrs Justice Lambert to issue her verdict. And whatever the outcome we succeeded in shining a spotlight on decisions made behind … Read more
GMC governance exposed
When Charlie Massey was appointed as CEO of the GMC in 2016, straight from his position at the Department of Health, 1,300 doctors signed a letter of no confidence, saying ‘His position as the Director … Read more
Day 3 in court
In the third and final day in court, Rory Dunlop KC and Peter Mant KC, on behalf of the GMC, defended their position to Mrs Justice Lambert, and our own barrister Tom de la Mare … Read more
Details of the hearing
We are looking forward to the third day in court on Monday June 9th. Please note that the arrangements for listening by Cloud Video Platform have changed since last time, so read the details below … Read more
Not Physician Associates
Today’s Guardian reports that Professor Leng’s review of Physician Associates (PAs) will recommend that they are renamed to something less confusing for patients. And they will also be required to tell patients, explicitly, that they … Read more
What haven’t they told us?
Despite our earlier attempts at getting full disclosure from the GMC we remain frustrated that some key information on decision-making has not been presented to the court. Our lawyers have written to the GMC asking … Read more
Judge wants to know – who made that decision?
Our second day in court went well, with both our barristers and the BMA’s hitting the message home. And the GMC started their defence with an emphasis on dry details of law. But the case … Read more
Day one in court
The skeleton arguments presented by our legal team are posted here. We have also uploaded the first and second witness statements of Professor Melville which were referred to today. This morning in court Tom de … Read more
Our legal arguments in full
Our barristers are presenting their arguments to the court this morning. Below are the full skeleton arguments and annexes that they will be presenting. The 4 annexes refer to:- Please remember that we are short … Read more
We’re in court on the 14th
The court has delayed the start of our case by 24 hours. The case is now booked for the 14th May at the High Court of Justice in the Strand, and will run over two … Read more
One week to go
On May 13th our judicial review of the GMC, the way they have regulated associates, will be heard in the High Court. This case has been made possible thanks to over £200,000 in public donations; … Read more
What exactly did Massey say?
Everyone was surprised at a Council meeting of the Royal College of Physicians Council meeting on 19th November, when Mr Massey of the GMC gave the impression that the GMC would accept College guidance on … Read more
Our daughter died in error
To lose a child is so very painful. It is not the right order of this world. However, to lose a child and then discover it was avoidable is the worst pain ever. Emily was … Read more
Judge rules against BMA
We are disappointed to hear the judge ruled against the BMA in their judicial review of the GMC, over the use of the term ‘medical professionals’ and applying “Good Medical Practice” to AAs and PAs. … Read more
Has the GMC breached its duty of candour in our court case?
In a judicial review case like ours, both sides are under an important legal obligation to be open with the Court and each other. This is called the duty of candour and is explained in … Read more
LEGAL UPDATE – PA safety data is admissible in court
The GMC has attempted to blindfold the court to important new evidence, and prevent us from responding to its lead witness. And it has failed. The GMC attempted to prevent us, and the Chesterton family, … Read more
Doctor replacement in general practice
Your FAQs on our upcoming court case against the GMC answered! The issue of doctor replacement by PAs in primary care is explained – and how our case will stop it.
Spread awareness
There are still many doctors that are unaware of our legal case. We are keen to spread awareness and get more support (and more donations to our legal fund). Our posters We’ve designed a series … Read more
Time for the Colleges to get off the fence?
With only 9 weeks to go, is it time for the Medical Royal Colleges and Specialist Societies to get off the fence? Now that we have seen the Oxford report, can they openly support and … Read more
No evidence of patient safety
The University of Oxford study published in the BMJ demonstrated the lack of evidence that Physician Associates (PAs) were safe, and found no data that showed deploying PAs or AAs even saves money. Now the Royal … Read more
Emergency Medicine College tightens the rules on supervision
Strict new rules on supervision of Physician Associates (PAs) in A&E have been issued by the Royal College of Emergency Medicine (RCEM). The requirements are now for ‘direct supervision by a senior clinician’ and for … Read more
Another coroner demands action
Another coroner has demanded action, after the death of an elderly lady seen by an unsupervised Physician Associate in A&E was sent home without a medical review. The PA had made a diagnosis of epistaxis … Read more
See you in court – May 13th
The case has now passed its first legal hurdle and been granted permission to proceed to a full High Court hearing. The GMC will be held to account, publicly, for the unsafe and pitifully light-touch … Read more
No role for PAs in general practice
The Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) have drawn a hard line. There is no role, they say, for Physician Associates (PAs) in General Practice. If that is the case then we should urgently pause … Read more
A pivotal moment
The GMC has opened the doors to Physician Associates (PAs) and Anaesthesia Associates (AAs) from several other countries to come to the UK. The list of 15 countries includes Bangladesh, Ghana, Switzerland and the USA. … Read more
The PSD Loophole
Anaesthesia Associates (AAs) are not legally allowed to prescribe drugs. They are not doctors. However various loopholes are being used to avoid this law because injecting drugs is obviously at the centre of anaesthetics. The … Read more